Historical Fiction Book Clubs
Readers of Historical Fiction... (these bulleted strategies can become teaching points.)
- Think about what is fact and what is fiction
- Read the historical note or author's to know how the author researched the book (think about when to read this note: before? After? In the middle? All three?)
- Consider what big idea about life the author is trying to communicate
- Re-read sections of the book to question how much of the story is fact
- Ask themselves how the character's experience is different because of the time they lived in
- Use knowledge about the time period to question the author. 1) develop questions they want to explore about the text/history; 2) wonder about reliability of sources; 3) reliability of the story - how is it historically accurate.
- Use prior knowledge to understand the text. Identify facts they know and new facts they are learning.
- Think about how this story connects to current events
- Use details in the story to make pictures in your mind of what is happening
- Read aloud to themselves to help understand the language/dialect of the time period
- Notice language and figures of speech that are particular to a time and place.
- Think about how the story is being told (diary, letter, story) and how that gives the reader a different understanding of the point of view being told.
- Understand that most issues are multi-faceted.
- Identify different points of view in a story.
- Think, "What do I know about this time period?" before they start reading.
- Make connections between other books and real life.
- Try to put themselves in the character's place both as a modern person and as someone who lived a long time ago.
- Think, "What if.... history was different."
- Use illustrations to better understand the time period and events.
- Use text to "test" generalizations.
- Dispute point of view and stereotypes or myths.
- Consult nonfiction sources to enhance understanding of historical fiction text.
Why Read Historical Fiction
- Through empathizing with characters, can develop an understanding of the experience of children at that time
- Historical fiction zooms in on one specific event, explores it and its impacts from one person's point of view
- History is people
- To explore the challenges of the past versus those of today
- To develop a richer understanding of the past
- To understand the complexity of the past (landscape of human history, warts and all...)
- To understand the role of individuals in history
- To encourage questions and to develop comfort with ambiguity
Historical Fiction Projects: Synthesizing Learning and providing evidence of thinking
- Time line of historical events and events in book
- Graphic Organizers
- T-charts - fact/fiction, historical facts and events/how the author presents them, past/present
- Venn Diagrams: compare/contrast characters, events, past and present
- Writing poetry to reflect perspectives. For example, if two characters have two different points of view, write a poem for two voices that reflects these perspectives
- Map of where the story takes place. Use symbols or icons to represent events in the timeline.
- Survey students' families to see how much information or knowledge they have about a particular historical event.
- Create a newspaper about a time period.
- Create 5 generation headlines to show how perspectives change over time or to show different perspectives.
- Create diary entries.
- Role playing
- Debates
- Readers Theater
- Story boards (6 panels - 1 statement about the human qualities exemplified by the text)
- Create "primary" sources (role play through letter writing or journaling)
- Head/Hands/Heart. Make a chart that explores how the character thinks, what they do, and how they feel. Generalize across the chart.
- Interview a character.
- Explore opposing points of view of the events in the story through creating t-shirt logos, bumper stickers, posters, infomercials.
Historical Fiction Book Club Sample Unit 1: Immigration
Tracey Greenberg PS442, Marguerite Ho PS72, Luisa Valentin PS1X, Jennifer Kaiser PS1X, Angela Turnier PS124
|
Monday |
Tuesday |
Wednesday |
Thursday |
Friday |
|
What is historical fiction? What are the features of historical fiction? |
More on features... Immersion in the Genre |
Comparing nonfiction, historical fiction, realistic fiction NF / HF / RF |
Readers of historical fiction think about what they already know about the period. |
Readers of HF are able to add to their prior knowledge. *use prior knowledge to expand knowledge. T-chart Prior knowledge/ New knowledge |
|
What is immigration? Look through immigration books. |
What are the four w's of our immigration stories? Who, where, when, why Readers ask questions to guide reading. |
What are the similarities and differences across our immigration stories? Readers can use charts to.... |
Readers of HF get to know the main character by noticing the kind of person s/he is and picturing what life was like |
HF readers pay attention to the problems that their characters face to learn more about the time period or event. |
|
Readers pause to think about the language or vocabulary that is unique to the time period. |
Culminating project: Family immigration oral histories. |
Readers reflect on what they have learned from one book in order to carry what they have learned to a second text. |
Readers compare the way different people handle similar situations and problems. |
Readers look back at books for big ideas about a time period. |
Historical Fiction Book Club Sample Unit 2: Learning about point of view through historical fiction
Mentor Texts: Malian's Song by Marge Bruchac and The Arrow Over the Door by Joseph Bruchac
Time Period: Revolutionary War
Writers: Amy Kopchains PS171, Irene DeichmanPS83
|
Monday |
Tuesday |
Wednesday |
Thursday |
Friday |
|
What is historical fiction? Read Malian's Song. Brain storm elements. Time period, identify character's place in time. |
What is fact? What is fiction? Look at author's note in Malian's Song. Identify elements that are based on historical fact and what is made up for the story. T-Chart. |
Identify point of view. Re-read Malian. How is Malian viewing the attack? |
Put self in character's place. What rituals/celebrations do our cultures use to deal with loss or change? Read end of Malian. |
What do I know about this time period? (Colonial America prior to Revolutionary War) KWL chart. What questions do you have about this period? |
|
Review perspective/ point of view. Assign book clubs. Three points of view. African American (War Comes to Will Freeman) Native American European (Johnny Tremain) In groups: predict point of view of characters. |
Roles in book club: Summarizer Questioner Word master (vocabulary) Facilitator (take notes on discussion) |
Read Aloud: The Arrow over the Door. First two chapters. Compare and Contrast point of view of the two characters. (Head/Hands/Heart) |
Read Aloud: The Arrow over the Door. Compare and Contrast point of view of the two characters.How do I hold on to details? |
Read Aloud: The Arrow over the Door. Compare and Contrast point of view of the two characters. Understand that there are many points of view in history. |
|
Read Aloud: The Arrow over the Door. Compare and Contrast the two characters. Cause and Effect: events leading to actions. |
Historical effects on different characters. |
End of unit projects: Mandatory writing projects Dated journals about the thoughts and feelings of a chosen character. Art project on a defining event in the character's life. |